I think what it is is that Nimoy is sexy with everything, from Kirk and McCoy and Uhura to Hortas and walls and EVERYTHING, whereas Quinto kind of...isn't, you know?

It's strange, but for some reason I'll almost always picture Amanda in a fic as the TOS version, and I don't know why. I loved Winona!Amanda. Maybe because TOS!Amanda was rocking that beehive all the time or something?